agile coaching Archives - Scrum Master Toolbox Podcast

Joshua McDonald: When Your Agile Enthusiasm Creates Resistance, Start With Trust

“Don’t assume they’re as enthusiastic about Agile and Scrum as you are.” – Joshua McDonald

Joshua McDonald starts the week with a failure story many Scrum Masters will recognize: stepping into a team and assuming the role, the expectations, and the Agile conversation were already understood.

The team had worked with a hands-off Scrum Master before, so Joshua’s attempts to facilitate events, talk about metrics, and bring more structure were received as interference. The pushback grew so strong he sensed people were talking to his manager about removing him. The turning point came when Joshua stopped leading with Scrum language and started rebuilding social equity through one-on-ones.

He asked what he could have done differently, acted on the feedback, and reminded himself and the team to assume positive intent. His lesson is direct: when we join a new team, trust is the work before the work. Go slow, understand how people operate, and bring suggestions through relationships before bringing them to the whole room.

Self-reflection Question: When you join a new team, what do you do first to understand their relationship with Scrum before you suggest changes?

Transform Your Agile Teams with Hard-Earned Lessons from Super-Experienced Scrum Masters

Do you wish you had decades of experience? Learn from the Best Scrum Masters In The World, Today! The Tips from the Trenches – Scrum Master edition audiobook includes hours of audio interviews with SM’s that have decades of experience: from Mike Cohn to Linda Rising, Christopher Avery, and many more. Super-experienced Scrum Masters share their hard-earned lessons with you. Learn those today, make your teams awesome!

About Joshua McDonald

Joshua is endlessly curious about better ways of working. He helps teams grow by blending experimentation, creativity, and AI with practical coaching. When a meeting feels routine, he’s already testing a new approach to make it more valuable. Energetic and inventive, he turns everyday collaboration into opportunities for team growth.

You can link with Joshua McDonald on LinkedIn.

Maria Skvortsova: When Agile Labels Hide Waterfall Reality — A Scrum Master’s Wake-Up Call in SAP Migration

“I realized that even if I like Scrum and Agile, and I think they are really good ways of thinking, some areas cannot adapt them because they are completely different from the mindset and ways of working.” — Maria Skvortsova

Maria came to Agile with the fire of a true believer. After a decade as a C++ developer, she’d found something that matched how she thought and felt about building software — something that went beyond controlling budgets and roadmaps. When a boutique SAP consulting company hired her as an Agile coach to transform their entire organization, she was all in. She built what she describes as a “really good” training for senior management, designed to sell them on Agile ways of working.

But when she stepped out of the PMO role and into a real SAP migration project as delivery manager, the ground shifted beneath her. The iron triangle — fixed cost, fixed scope, fixed time — ruled everything. Teams ran “sprints” that were really just boxed iterations with no feedback loops, no value delivery, just a march toward a go-live date.

Maria realized she was putting Agile labels on a fundamentally waterfall process. The hardest part wasn’t the discovery — it was accepting that she needed to redirect her energy to environments where Agile could genuinely take root, rather than forcing it where the mindset simply didn’t exist. Her advice: recognize when labels don’t match reality as quickly as possible, and have the courage to choose environments that align with how you want to work.

Self-reflection Question: Are you putting Agile labels on processes that are fundamentally waterfall? How quickly would you recognize the mismatch — and what would you do about it?

Transform Your Agile Teams with Hard-Earned Lessons from Super-Experienced Scrum Masters

About Maria Skvortsova

Maria is a Delivery Manager and Agile Coach who thrives in complexity, bringing clarity to chaotic environments. With a decade in C++ development and a background in professional opera, she blends technical precision with human empathy, helping enterprise teams move beyond task execution to collaborate seamlessly and perform like a synchronized, high-impact orchestra.

You can link with Maria Skvortsova on LinkedIn.

Christian Thordal: When Applying Scrum By The Book Fails, Understanding Context Before Changing The System

“I treated Scrum like a military SOP — follow the book, execute the steps. But I failed to see that the context was really the tipping point. What looked like a problem was actually their solution.” – Christian Thordal

Christian shares a hard-won lesson from his time coaching three RPA teams at one of Denmark’s largest banks during the pandemic. He inherited teams running six-week sprints with half-hour planning sessions that amounted to little more than putting items on a calendar. As a former Danish Army officer, Christian’s instinct was to fix the obvious deviation from the Scrum Guide — the sprint length.

He advocated for shorter feedback loops and eventually convinced the Product Owner, who also served as the director, to try two-week sprints. The first planning session was a disaster.

There was yelling and scolding, and it became clear that the real problem had nothing to do with sprint length. The teams had no proper backlog. The six-week sprints actually worked because they gave teams enough time to go out to the business, discover work, and deliver it within a single cycle.

Christian realized he had been applying Scrum mechanically without understanding how work entered the system. He started attending business analyst and PO meetings, uncovered the backlog gap, and helped the teams build a proper one. His key insight: what looks like a symptom can actually be a pragmatic solution to real constraints. Understand the system before you change it.

In this episode, we refer to the book Scrum: The Art of Doing Twice the Work in Half the Time, by Jeff Sutherland.

Self-reflection Question: When was the last time you assumed a team’s practice was wrong, only to discover it was a reasonable adaptation to their context? How might you investigate the “why” behind existing processes before proposing changes?

Transform Your Agile Teams with Hard-Earned Lessons from Super-Experienced Scrum Masters

About Christian Thordal

Christian Thordal is a former Danish Army officer turned Agile Coach. He works with leaders and teams to create clarity, accountability, and momentum in complex organizations. His approach blends military leadership principles with modern product development, helping organizations move from discussion and strategy to real execution and measurable results.

You can link with Christian Thordal on LinkedIn.

Peter Merel: AI Alignment Is the Agile Coach’s Next Frontier — Using Throughput Accounting and Pull-Based Transformation to Prove Value

“Our jobs ARE about alignment. Alignment is how do we get all of the people and all of the tools to work together for mutual benefit.” – Peter Merel

Peter Merel brings a provocative perspective on the biggest challenge facing agile professionals today: AI and agile alignment. With AI rapidly advancing, Peter observes that everyone in the agile community is afraid for their jobs — but argues this fear is misplaced. The real challenge isn’t replacement; it’s alignment. How do we get biological and electronic entities to work together for mutual benefit? Peter’s answer begins with pull-based transformation — building a thin steel thread from business through to DevOps, proving it works with a small group, then growing it. He connects this to Goldratt’s throughput accounting, arguing that throughput (operating expense plus net profit) is the only metric immune to Goodhart’s Law.

From throughput, Peter derives three flows: value flow (throughput itself), workflow (the first derivative — what increases value flow), and learning flow (the second derivative — what improves workflow). He then introduces the pirate metrics (AARRR) — acquisition, activation, retention, referral, and revenue — as market constraints that can be analyzed through Theory of Constraints. Peter’s frustration is that 25 years after Agile began, most business stakeholders still can’t identify their market bottleneck. Without that knowledge, he argues, priorities are meaningless. The path forward for agile coaches? Bring scientific rigor to transformation, measure what matters, and prove value before scaling.

In this episode, we refer to FAST Agile, Joe Justice’s work with Tesla and WikiSpeed, and the connection between throughput accounting and agile transformation metrics.

Self-reflection Question: Can you identify the single biggest market constraint limiting your organization’s throughput right now — and if not, how confident are you that your current priorities are the right ones?

Transform Your Agile Teams with Hard-Earned Lessons from Super-Experienced Scrum Masters

About Peter Merel

Credited in the first agile book (XP Embraced), keynoted the first agile conference, invented the first agile training game, founded the xscale alliance, authored the agile way, Peter developed software by hand for forty years, coached agile in person for twenty years, and is working now to revolutionize the AI alignment landscape.

You can link with Peter Merel on LinkedIn. You can also find his work at agile.way.pm.

Peter Merel: When a Hub-and-Spoke Executive Hijacks Your Agile Transformation — And What to Do About It

“Either you’re going to do what you know works, or you’re going to step away. Either way, you’re not going to do damage to your client.” – Peter Merel

After a successful transformation at Commonwealth Bank of Australia, Peter Merel moved to Westpac, another major Australian bank, expecting to replicate the same approach. He found an executive who appeared eager to support an agile transformation — but this executive saw agile as the ideal form of micromanagement.

Everything and everyone revolved around this one individual, and as Peter began facilitating conversations that didn’t hub on the executive, the executive felt disempowered. Peter was blind to this dynamic — he had never encountered it before. The situation deteriorated because Peter had been hired to run a push-based transformation, when he knew from experience that only pull-based transformation works.

At Commonwealth Bank, he had built a thin steel thread from business through to DevOps with a small group, proved it worked, and then grown it organically. At Westpac, he let himself be persuaded to push change into the organization, and it compromised everything. The lesson Peter shares is stark: if you can’t do what you know works, and you can’t step away, then you are the problem. He also warns that when coaches fail this way, they make life harder for whoever comes next — a responsibility that’s easy to overlook in the moment.

In this segment, we talk about pull-based transformation and why push-based change programs consistently fail in large organizations.

Self-reflection Question: Are you currently in a situation where you’ve compromised on your approach to change — and if so, are you doing more damage by staying than you would by stepping away?

Featured Book of the Week: The Agile Way by Peter Merel

Peter’s own book, The Agile Way, is his modern translation of the Tao Te Ching — a 3,000-year-old text he argues was originally about how to achieve agile development in organizations large and small. Peter first started translating this text in 1989, and after decades of iteration, the book draws connections between ancient wisdom and modern agile practices — XP, Lean, Theory of Constraints, throughput accounting, and permaculture.

As Peter explains, “The sage in Lao Tzu is Shang Ren — agile people. This is a book about agile people, agility, and it always was.” The book is available at agile.way.pm, and Kent Beck, who wrote the foreword, calls it “a dangerous little book” — dangerous in the same sense as the word extreme.

Transform Your Agile Teams with Hard-Earned Lessons from Super-Experienced Scrum Masters

About Peter Merel

You can link with Peter Merel on LinkedIn. You can also find his work at agile.way.pm.